Questions leaders ask
Does NIS2 require post-quantum cryptography for water and wastewater utilities?
Not by name. NIS2 lists drinking water and waste water in Annex I as sectors of high criticality, and Article 21(2)(h) requires policies and procedures on the use of cryptography and, where appropriate, encryption. That obligation covers the network and information systems behind the essential service, so telemetry, treatment controls and remote access are in scope. A competent authority can reasonably ask how your cryptography policy treats algorithms that NIST will deprecate in 2030.
Does America's Water Infrastructure Act say anything about quantum or cryptography?
No. Section 2013 requires community water systems serving more than 3,300 people to certify a risk and resilience assessment every five years, and the assessment must cover electronic, computer or other automated systems, including their security, with an emergency response plan that addresses cybersecurity six months later. The EPA's May 2024 enforcement alert shows inspectors now read those sections closely. Quantum-vulnerable cryptography in your SCADA and telemetry is a risk to automated systems, and the next cycle, opening on 31 March 2030 for the largest systems, is the natural place to record it.
Which water SCADA and telemetry protocols are vulnerable to quantum attack?
Any protocol or tunnel that uses RSA or ECDSA for key exchange, certificates or authentication: DNP3 Secure Authentication version 5 update keys, OPC UA security modes on historians and engineering workstations, and every IPsec or TLS VPN that carries telemetry over cellular or the internet. Modbus/TCP, the most common protocol in treatment works, carries no cryptography at all, which is a different problem. The symmetric parts, such as AES and HMAC, hold up. Our free OT Protocol Quantum Vulnerability Scanner maps this for the protocols you select.
Can a telemetry outstation or dosing PLC run post-quantum cryptography?
Some can. Benchmarks from the pqm4 project put ML-KEM-768 key generation at roughly 100,000 clock cycles and about 1.5KB of stack on an ARM Cortex-M4, within reach of recent controllers and out of reach of older ones. The bigger constraint on a water network is bandwidth: an ML-KEM-768 exchange adds about 2,272 bytes, roughly two seconds on a 9,600 baud radio link, which matters when you poll hundreds of outstations. Classify each device as algorithm-agile, firmware-updatable or algorithm-fixed and terminate post-quantum tunnels at a gateway for the rest.
Who is our regulator for this in the UK?
Under the NIS Regulations 2018 the Secretary of State is the competent authority for drinking water in England and the Welsh Government in Wales, with the Drinking Water Inspectorate performing the operational duties for both. The Drinking Water Quality Regulator does the same in Scotland. The threshold is supply to 200,000 or more people. Companies in scope file an NCSC Cyber Assessment Framework return each year and report NIS incidents within 72 hours. The NCSC timeline, discovery by 2028, highest-priority migration by 2031 and completion by 2035, is the pace your CAF return will be read against.
What does the Drinking Water Directive change?
Directive (EU) 2020/2184 has applied since 12 January 2023 and replaces reactive testing with a risk-based approach to water safety: risk assessment and management of catchment areas by July 2027, and of supply systems and domestic distribution by January 2029. The directive is about water quality rather than cyber security, but the supply system risk assessment is where many utilities will first document their treatment controls and telemetry as a risk to safe supply, and cryptography that will be deprecated in 2030 belongs in it.
Does the recast Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive matter for cyber security?
Indirectly. Directive (EU) 2024/3019 entered into force on 1 January 2025 and must be transposed by 31 July 2027. It drives more monitoring, more digital control and energy-neutral plants by 2045, which means more connected instruments and more remote access at every treatment plant. The cyber obligations for wastewater come from NIS2 Annex I sector 7, and the two directives together mean a wastewater operator will be adding connected equipment at exactly the time it should be specifying algorithm agility.
What is harvest now, decrypt later, and why does it matter for a water utility?
An adversary records encrypted traffic or copies encrypted data today and stores it until a quantum computer can break the encryption. Network drawings, dosing logic, telemetry configurations and customer records stay useful to an attacker for decades, far longer than the time until a cryptographically relevant quantum computer is expected. Recorded vendor remote access sessions and telemetry tunnels carry the same risk. The 2023 Unitronics campaign shows that water systems are already on the target list for actors with the patience to collect.
Where should a water utility start?
Three things: extend the cryptographic inventory into OT, starting with the telemetry head-end and the IT-OT boundary; run a protocol scan and classify every outstation, PLC and dosing controller by whether it can take a cryptographic update; and write algorithm agility and a post-quantum firmware roadmap into every telemetry, RTU, PLC and SCADA tender from now on. Those three give your board or council the evidence to set priorities, and they slot into the next AWIA assessment or CAF return without a separate programme.
Do we have to replace every outstation before 2035?
No. Replacement of algorithm-fixed outstations and controllers should follow your asset management plan and treatment works refurbishment in the 2031 to 2035 window. What matters now is that no new algorithm-fixed device enters the estate, and that the head-end, the boundary and the corporate systems, which run on standard hardware, migrate first. Gateway termination covers the outstations that wait.
What should we show the board or council about quantum risk?
Five numbers: inventory coverage of treatment works and telemetry links, the count of algorithm-fixed devices and their replacement dates, the records that must stay confidential beyond 2030, how many SCADA, telemetry and PLC vendors have a post-quantum firmware roadmap on file, and budget and milestones against the 2030 and 2035 deadlines and your next regulatory cycle.
What does QSECDEF offer water and wastewater utilities for free?
Everything on this page. The two-minute readiness check scores your water and wastewater programme and routes you to the right next step. The free tools, including the OT Protocol Quantum Vulnerability Scanner and the OT Cryptographic Asset Prioritisation Matrix, run in your browser with no registration. The weekly peer call runs every Tuesday at 15:00 CET and is open to anyone. Sample lectures from the 170-plus expert library are linked above, and the page is reviewed as the mandates change; the date beside the key facts is the last check.
Which QSECDEF course should a water and wastewater team take first?
It depends on the role. Board, council and executives start with the Certified Quantum Business Professional bootcamp, about 22 hours self-paced across ten modules. Security, risk and IT teams take Introduction to Quantum Cyber Security, four to five hours online with a QSECDEF certificate. OT and SCADA engineers and telemetry leads take PQC Migration for SCADA and OT Networks, a full day covering DNP3, IEC 61850, Modbus/TCP and OPC UA. Whoever will run the migration takes CPQCPM, the Certified Post Quantum Cryptography Programme Manager course: ten hours live online over five weeks, with the next public cohort in January 2027.
Can QSECDEF run private training or a workshop for our water company or municipal utility?
Yes. QSECDEF runs private CPQCPM cohorts for a single organisation, live online or in person, and private deliveries of the sector courses listed under Equip your people for your OT and SCADA engineers. Board and leadership workshops are built on your own exposure and obligations and end with an agreed position on quantum risk. Use the contact button in the For your utility section and tell us your timeline.
How do we find vetted suppliers or consultants for a water and wastewater PQC migration?
Through the QSECDEF Expert Members directory. Every listed member has been vetted, has signed the Members' Charter and has presented to the community. You can filter by consulting and services, technology vendor or enablement and investment, and send a request for further information from the member's own page. QSECDEF is vendor-neutral and sells training, not migration products, so the shortlist stays yours.
Is QSECDEF membership relevant to a water company or municipal utility?
Two routes. QSECDEF membership gives your team the self-paced courses, the full lecture archive, the weekly call and 25 per cent off CPQCPM and partner training. Expert Membership is for the builders, consultancies and technology vendors serving water and wastewater who want to be found by the people reading this page; it includes a showcase listing with an enquiry form, the Industry Conversations and speaking slots at the annual QSECDEF symposium.
Is QSECDEF selling a migration product?
No. QSECDEF is a vendor-neutral membership network. We train people and connect them with peers and peer-reviewed experts; we do not sell migration software or services.
How much time does the training take?
CPQCPM is ten hours of live instruction over five weeks, two hours a week. PQC Migration for SCADA and OT Networks is a full day of six hours, in person or online. The Quantum Cyber Security course is 4 to 5 hours, self-paced. The business bootcamp is self-paced at your own speed.
Ask a practitioner, liveThe free weekly call runs every Tuesday at 15:00 CET. Bring your question.
Join the Tuesday call →